Monday, March 19, 2012

Comic Mini-Reviews Week of March 14th, 2012

This week, Batman and Robin kills, Conan thrills, and Batgirl spills.

Batgirl #7 – Look, I'm a big, big Gail Simone fan but I just can't do it anymore. I'm sorry! There's just something about Batgirl that is lacking! It might be the book's almost complete lack of interesting supporting cast, intriguing villains, or something else. If I had to guess, it would be that Simone went into the book feeling the need to please to please to many people. The result has been a kind of bland, tapioca comic that makes Batgirl and Barbara Gordon kind of boring. I think a large part of the blame could be placed on Ardian Syaf whose art is only dynamic and exciting a couple of pages every issue. Regardless of where the book's failings emanate from, I am pretty sure this is my last Batgirl issue. It makes me sad to say it but, with my limited comics budget, I just can't afford to buy books I am not enjoying. To that end, Batgirl was always placed on the bottom of my weekly comic pile. Really, that's the most damning thing I can say.

Batman and Robin #7 - Holy cow. I wouldn't say issue seven wrapped up the first arc in the way I expected. I am still really impressed by Batman and Robin and I am extremely interested to see where the story goes from here. I am sure there are some readers out there that felt the extremely emotional and violent nature of the issue was over-the-top. I can see that but I disagree. Batman and Robin has been slowly building to a dramatic conclusion and that's what we got. It's a story about fathers and sons and nothing creates emotions quite like family.

Batwoman #7 – I like that Williams and Blackman are continuing some of the trends established by Greg Rucka's work with the character. Batwoman is positioned to deal with the kinds of threats that rarely make it onto the pages of Batman these days, like magic and mystical type stuff. I would not say that the series is faltering, but it doesn't seem quite as dynamic without Williams III on art. Amy Reeder has been a solid replacement, but she's leaving the book because of creative differences. Her replacement is the solid Trevor McCarthy. Neither artist is on the level of Williams, but I understand that his style is not conducive to monthly deadlines. However, if I had to have someone fill in, I would prefer Reeder to McCarthy.

Captain America #9 – Cap's scrawny but, thankfully, he's got Sharon Carter. The majority of the issue focuses on her attempt to convince the Machinesmith to tell her what is wrong with Steve Rogers. It seems that Ed Brubaker is trying his hand at more traditional superheroics compared to his espionage filled work on the character. The series so far is a lot of fun and the recent issues with art by Alan Davis and Mark Farmer have evoked a style of sophisticated, old school comic book storytelling that is rarely seen these days.

Conan, The Barbarian #2 – Conan's a badass. No, seriously, that's my big takeaway from this issue. Really, there's not much to analyze. Brian Wood's script is dynamic and engrossing. Becky Cloonan's art is pitch-perfect and gorgeous. Dave Stewarts' coloring is befitting of his title as “best in the business.” Really, there's not much more to say about this issue. Fantastic stuff so far.

Demon Knights #7 – What?! The siege is finally over?! Wow. The poster child for decompressed storytelling in the New 52 finally brings its first storyline to an end. What's crazy is that despite taking seven issues to come to fruition, it still ends abruptly somehow. One page, the bad guys have essentially won; the next, the good guys have turned the tables and it's all over. That kind of thing happens all the time, but this felt a little forced. I can't say it hasn't been enjoyable, but I think I am switching to trade-waiting on Demon Knights. I just think I will enjoy it more in complete story form.

Frankenstein, Agent of S.H.A.D.E. #7 – Thanks to fun tools like a buzzsaw gun and an exploding sword, the original Creature Commandos turn out to be not much a threat at all. There are many things to love about this issue, but the thing that stood out to me was that we FINALLY got to see Ray Palmer in action again. On that note, it seems that Palmer may never have been the Atom in the new continuity, but it's kind of hard to know for certain. The ending is a nice cliffhanger that should led to an interesting next issue. I think Jeff Lemire is an innately good storyteller and has a real flair for timing. It's surprising just how different Alberto Ponticelli's art looks with someone else inking it. His art is given a much smoother look by Walden Wong.

Green Lantern #7 – There's been a Sinestro-napping! After learning about the other color Corps rather quickly back when Geoff Johns started introducing them, we still know very little about the Indigo Tribe. With issue seven of Green Lantern, we're finally going to learn about the mysterious wielders of light purple plasma as they make their move to capture Sinestro. Strangely, it seems like the Tribe planned poorly. I mean, they just happened to decide to kidnap Sinestro when he was on earth bothering Hal Jordan? They couldn't have just waited thirty minutes and caught him while he was headed back out of earth's atmosphere? Also, why would Sinestro and the leader of the Indigo Tribe create green constructs that look like earth technology? It's not a big thing and it may have just been Doug Mahnke being creative but it seemed a little out of place. Regardless, the gun Sinestro creates looks fabulous. Green Lantern is still a solid book with great art, even if it has stumbled somewhat since the relaunch.

The Ray #4 – How do you defeat a villain that alters reality? You have him hit the Cosmic Reset button using light hypnosis, of course! Oh comics, you so crazy! In all seriousness, The Ray #4 brings the mini-series starring the revamped light-manipulating hero to an end in pretty interesting fashion. There's something appropriate about a New 52 mini-series ending with a retcon that essentially wipes the story told in issues two through four out of continuity. The Ray is a fun new character, and I wouldn't mind seeing more of him. As far as I am concerned, Justin Gray, Jimmy Palmiotti, Jamal Igle, and Rich Perrotta hit all the necessary notes for a character revamp—the character was likable, the supporting cast was strong, and the history of the character's former iterations remains intact.

The Shade #6 – That does it, I demand Javier Pulido illustrate everything Robinson writes from now on! I am really enjoying The Shade, and I like that James Robinson is using the twelve issue maxi-series to explore DC's less developed corners. But I can't help but feeling that the plot is in danger of getting lost along the way. I realize that twelve issues is a large number for a mini-series, but The Shade feels more like an ongoing book than a limited one. Then again, I guess that's fine if we continue to be introduced to characters like La Sangre and Montpellier, a Bangladeshi-born snake-themed crime-fighting detective. I guess all I am saying is that DC should just give Robinson a “James Robinson Explores the World of DC” book. Oh wait...

Thief of Thieves #2 – Issue two of Nick Spencer and Robert Kirkman's thief story revolves around the central plot point of the series so far: Why does the world's greatest thief want to quit? As with the first installment, much of the issue is devoted to flashbacks that fill out the main characters and his motivations. So far it is a good read and the art by Shawn Martinbrough and Felix Serrano fits the atmosphere of the book perfectly. This is a series with a big time lineage and a lot of promise..hopefully it will live up to it.

Wolverine and the X-men #7- Various sh*ts hit a plethora of fans. As Wolverine and Quentin Quire are duking it out in an interstellar casino, Kitty Pride and the rest of the faculty are having problems of their own. In last week's FIGcast I mentioned that this was the weakest issue of the run so far. I stand by that assessment, if only for the fact that it felt a little frantic at points. There was just so much going on. However, there was real character development with the intelligent Brood, some fun moments with Kid Gladiator, and a telepathic shotgun. This is still one of my favorite books each month. Jason Aaron's scripts couldn't be more enjoyable and Nick Bradshaw's pencils are perfect for the tone the book is trying set.

No comments:

Post a Comment